Updated on 2th October, 2026
A drop of pond water, a handful of soil or the surface of a plant can contain many different microorganisms. Some can be seen under a microscope or grown in the laboratory, while others are difficult to observe or cultivate. How, then, do scientists discover which microbes are present and understand what they do?
Microbiologists use several complementary methods. Microscopy helps reveal microbial cells and their surroundings; cultivation allows living organisms to be studied; and DNA-based methods help identify and compare microorganisms directly from samples. Each method provides a different kind of evidence, and each has limitations.
Discovering a microbe is therefore often a gradual process. Researchers may first detect an unfamiliar sequence, then try to locate the organism in its habitat, grow it under suitable conditions and investigate its properties. Combining these approaches helps turn an initial observation into a clearer understanding of microbial life.
What does it mean to discover a microbe?
In everyday language, discovery might sound like finding a completely new organism. In microbiology, however, the word can describe several different steps.
A scientist might observe an unfamiliar cell under a microscope, detect a previously unrecognized DNA sequence, isolate an organism in culture or formally describe a new species. These achievements are related, but one does not automatically establish the others.
For example, a DNA sequence that has no close match in a reference database may belong to a poorly studied microbial lineage. But the sequence alone may not reveal the organism’s appearance, nutritional requirements or ecological role. More evidence is needed before researchers can confidently describe what they have found.
Microbial discovery also includes identifying known microorganisms in places where they have not previously been studied. Finding a familiar bacterial group in a new environment can help researchers understand its distribution and ask how it survives there.
Why are microorganisms difficult to discover?
Microorganisms are diverse, and their small size makes them difficult to study directly. Bacteria, archaea, microscopic fungi, algae and other microbial eukaryotes can share an environment while having very different structures and growth requirements.
Many habitats are also physically complex. In soil, for example, microorganisms can live on mineral surfaces, around plant roots, within small pores or in films of water. Conditions may differ over very short distances: one area may contain oxygen, while a nearby pocket has little or none.
The method used to investigate a sample influences what researchers detect. A growth medium may favour organisms that multiply quickly under laboratory conditions, while a DNA extraction method may recover genetic material more efficiently from some cells than others. As a result, no single technique provides a complete, perfectly unbiased view of a microbial community.
Viruses add another layer of complexity. They are not cells and require a suitable host to reproduce. Methods designed to investigate cellular microorganisms do not necessarily reveal the viruses present in the same sample.
Collecting a sample: the first step in discovery
Microbial discovery begins with a question. A researcher might ask which bacteria live near plant roots, how microbial communities differ between lake depths or whether a particular environment contains organisms capable of degrading a pollutant.
The question guides the choice of samples. To study a lake, researchers may collect water from several locations or depths. To study a plant-associated community, they may compare soil close to the roots with soil farther away. Recording temperature, pH, oxygen conditions and other relevant features helps place the microbial results in context.
Careful sampling is essential because a single sample may not represent an entire environment. Microbial communities can change with location, season, depth and recent environmental conditions. Researchers therefore use an appropriate sampling design and, when possible, collect independent samples that allow them to examine variation.
How samples are handled also matters. Delays or unsuitable storage conditions can alter the community or damage molecules that researchers want to measure. The best preservation method depends on the question: a sample intended for cultivation may need different handling from one collected for DNA or RNA analysis.
Looking at microbes through a microscope
Microscopy allows scientists to observe microorganisms that are too small to see clearly with the unaided eye. It can show cell shape, size, arrangement and, in some cases, the relationship between microorganisms and their surroundings.
A light microscope can reveal many bacteria, yeasts, microscopic algae and other microbial cells. Stains are often used to improve contrast or highlight particular features. For example, the Gram stain separates many bacteria into Gram-positive and Gram-negative groups based on how their cells respond to the staining procedure.
This distinction is useful, but it is only a starting point. A Gram stain does not provide a complete identification, and not all bacteria are reliably classified by it. Similarly, cell shape alone is rarely enough to identify an organism: microorganisms that appear similar can differ substantially in their genes and physiology.
Fluorescence microscopy and microbial identity
Some microscopy methods use fluorescent dyes or probes to make particular cells or structures visible. One example is fluorescence in situ hybridization, commonly called FISH.
In microbial FISH, a labelled probe binds to a complementary target sequence inside a cell. Researchers often design probes to recognize ribosomal RNA associated with a particular microbial group. They can then examine where the labelled cells occur within a sample.
This is useful because it connects genetic identification with physical location. For instance, researchers may investigate whether a microbial group is attached to a surface or positioned near another group in a community. The result depends on appropriate probe design, sample preparation and controls; a weak or absent signal does not automatically prove that the target organism is absent.
Electron microscopy can provide much finer structural detail than ordinary light microscopy. However, it requires specialized equipment and preparation, and a detailed image does not by itself establish an organism’s identity or ecological function.
Growing microorganisms in the laboratory
Cultivation involves providing conditions that allow microorganisms to grow. Researchers may use liquid media, solid media containing agar or more specialized systems designed to reproduce aspects of a natural habitat.
When a microorganism grows on solid medium, it may produce a visible colony. Researchers can transfer material from a colony and check its purity to obtain an isolate. A pure culture allows them to study one microorganism without the other members of its original community.
Living cultures are especially valuable for testing what an organism can do. Researchers can examine which nutrients support growth, how the organism responds to oxygen or temperature, and whether it produces particular enzymes or other compounds. They can also test interactions between different microorganisms under controlled conditions.
For example, if DNA analysis suggests that a bacterium has genes associated with the use of a particular carbon source, a growth experiment can help test whether the isolate uses that source under the conditions provided. The experiment may support or challenge the prediction, although it still represents the conditions tested in the laboratory.
Why do some microbes not grow on routine media?
A laboratory plate cannot reproduce every feature of a natural environment. Some microorganisms grow slowly or require particular nutrients, temperatures, pH levels or oxygen conditions. Others may depend on compounds supplied by neighbouring organisms or be sensitive to substances present in a medium.
For this reason, failure to grow on one medium does not prove that an organism can never be cultivated. “Not yet cultivated” can be a more accurate description when suitable conditions have not been found.
Researchers can adjust media and incubation conditions to recover organisms missed by routine approaches. For example, work on bacteria from soil and termite-associated samples has shown that nutrient-poor media, longer incubation and different atmospheric conditions, combined with molecular screening, can help recover previously uncultivated groups. These conditions are useful examples, not a universal recipe for all microbes.
Cultivation remains selective: the microorganisms recovered are those able to grow under the chosen conditions. A plate is therefore a window into part of the community, not a complete inventory of everything present in the original sample.
Discovering microorganisms through DNA
Scientists can study microorganisms without first growing them by extracting genetic material directly from an environmental sample. These are known as culture-independent approaches.
After DNA extraction, researchers sequence selected genetic regions or DNA fragments and compare them with reference sequences. This can reveal groups that are difficult to cultivate and help researchers compare communities across habitats.
Culture-independent does not mean bias-free. The result depends on sampling, preservation, DNA extraction, sequencing and data analysis. An organism may be missed because its DNA was not recovered efficiently, its target sequence was not amplified well or it is present at a level below detection.
Reference databases also matter. If a microorganism has few close relatives in the database, its sequence may be assigned only to a broad group or remain unidentified. An unfamiliar sequence can be an important clue, but it should not automatically be called a new species.
What does 16S rRNA gene sequencing reveal?
The 16S ribosomal RNA gene is a widely used marker for studying bacteria and archaea. It contains regions that are similar across many organisms and regions that vary. These differences help researchers compare sequences and place them within known microbial groups.
In a typical study, researchers extract DNA from a sample and use the polymerase chain reaction, or PCR, to amplify a selected part of the 16S rRNA gene. They then sequence the amplified DNA and compare the results with reference databases.
This approach can help answer questions such as whether bacterial communities differ between two soil environments or whether a particular bacterial group is detected across several water samples. It is particularly useful for examining patterns across multiple samples.
However, 16S sequencing does not always identify organisms to species level. Closely related species can share very similar sequences, and the level of detail depends on the region sequenced, the quality of the data and the reference database. Even sequencing the full gene does not guarantee that every species or strain can be distinguished.
The results also need careful interpretation. Some organisms have different numbers of copies of the 16S rRNA gene, and laboratory steps can influence how many sequences are obtained from each group. Therefore, the proportion of sequence reads assigned to a group is not automatically the exact proportion of living cells in the sample.
The 16S rRNA gene is used for bacteria and archaea, not as a universal marker for all microbes. Fungal studies often use the internal transcribed spacer, or ITS, region, while other microbial eukaryotes and viruses require different targets or approaches.
What is shotgun metagenomics?
Shotgun metagenomics takes a broader approach. Instead of targeting one marker gene, researchers sequence DNA fragments from the sample more generally. Computer analyses are then used to examine those fragments, identify possible sources and investigate genes.
Metagenomics can provide clues about both microbial identity and biological capabilities. In a soil sample, for example, researchers might detect genes associated with nutrient cycling. They may also assemble overlapping DNA fragments into longer sequences and group some of these sequences into metagenome-assembled genomes.
A metagenome-assembled genome can offer insight into an organism that has not been isolated, but it is a reconstruction from a mixture of DNA. Researchers need to assess whether the reconstruction is incomplete or contains sequences from more than one organism.
A further distinction is essential: finding a gene does not prove that the corresponding process is occurring in the environment. A gene may indicate that a microorganism has the potential to perform a function, but researchers need additional evidence to determine whether it is expressed and whether the predicted activity occurs under the conditions being studied.
Can researchers tell whether microbes are alive or active?
Detecting microbial DNA does not necessarily mean that the organism was alive when the sample was collected. DNA can remain in an environment after cells die, and living cells may differ in their level of activity.
Researchers use additional approaches to investigate activity. Metatranscriptomics, for example, examines RNA transcripts from a community to investigate which genes are being expressed. Measurements of metabolites or changes in environmental chemicals can provide further clues about microbial processes.
These approaches have limitations too. Detecting an RNA transcript does not always establish how much functional protein is present or how quickly a process is occurring. Likewise, a chemical change in a mixed community may not reveal which organism was responsible.
Cultivation, microscopy, genetic data and controlled experiments can help connect these pieces of evidence. The strongest conclusion usually comes from asking a clear question and choosing methods that address different parts of it.
Why are controls important?
Microbial DNA can enter samples from collection materials, laboratory surfaces and reagents. This is especially important when a sample contains very little microbial material: even a small amount of contamination can have a noticeable effect on the result.
Researchers therefore process negative controls alongside samples. An extraction blank, for example, is taken through the DNA extraction process without the environmental sample. It can help identify DNA introduced during that stage. Other controls can help assess additional steps in the workflow.
Controls do not automatically eliminate contamination, but they provide evidence researchers can use when interpreting the results. If a microbial sequence appears in both a sample and an extraction blank, researchers need to investigate its possible origin before drawing conclusions.
How the methods work together: a soil example
Imagine that researchers want to investigate microorganisms living near the roots of a plant.
They begin by collecting soil from several plants and from comparison areas farther from the roots. They record relevant environmental conditions and include controls during collection and laboratory analysis.
Under a microscope, they may observe cells attached to root surfaces or soil particles. Cultivation can provide living isolates whose growth requirements and activities can be tested. A 16S rRNA gene survey can help compare bacterial and archaeal patterns across samples, while shotgun metagenomics may reveal genes associated with functions of interest.
If a metagenome contains genes linked to nitrogen transformations, the researchers can use that finding to develop a more specific question. They might then measure changes in nitrogen compounds or test an isolate under controlled conditions. The initial gene detection guides the investigation; it does not prove that the process was active in the soil.
This example shows why combining approaches is useful. Each method contributes a different piece of evidence, and together they provide a clearer basis for understanding the community.
Comparing the main methods
| Method | What it can help researchers learn | A key limitation |
|---|---|---|
| Microscopy | What cells look like and where they occur in a sample | Appearance alone often cannot identify an organism |
| Cultivation | How living isolates grow and behave under tested conditions | Some organisms do not grow under the selected conditions |
| 16S rRNA gene sequencing | Which bacterial and archaeal groups are represented and how patterns differ between samples | Species-level identification is not always possible; sequence proportions are not exact cell counts |
| Shotgun metagenomics | Which DNA sequences and genes are present, including possible functional capabilities | A gene indicates potential, not necessarily activity |
| RNA and chemical measurements | Clues about gene expression and processes occurring in a community | Further evidence may be needed to link an activity to a particular organism |
From detection to understanding
Microbial discovery is not limited to finding a new species. It also involves learning where microorganisms live, how they grow and what roles they may play in their surroundings.
A microscope can reveal cells and their location. A culture allows researchers to investigate living organisms. DNA sequencing can uncover diversity that routine cultivation misses, while RNA and chemical measurements can help explore activity. Each result becomes more meaningful when researchers understand the method’s limitations and compare it with other evidence.
By bringing these approaches together, microbiologists can move from detecting an unfamiliar sequence or cell toward a more complete understanding of the microorganism and its environment.
References
- Amann, R., & Fuchs, B. M. (2008). Single-cell identification in microbial communities by improved fluorescence in situ hybridization techniques. Nature Reviews Microbiology, 6(5), 339–348. https://doi.org/10.1038/nrmicro1888
- Donachie, S. P., Foster, J. S., & Brown, M. V. (2007). Culture clash: Challenging the dogma of microbial diversity. The ISME Journal, 1(2), 97–99. https://doi.org/10.1038/ismej.2007.22
- Hazen, T. C., Rocha, A. M., & Techtmann, S. M. (2013). Advances in monitoring environmental microbes. Current Opinion in Biotechnology, 24(3), 526–533. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.copbio.2012.10.020
- Johnson, J. S., Spakowicz, D. J., Hong, B.-Y., Petersen, L. M., Demkowicz, P., Chen, L., Leopold, S. R., Hanson, B. M., Agresta, H. O., Gerstein, M., Sodergren, E., & Weinstock, G. M. (2019). Evaluation of 16S rRNA gene sequencing for species and strain-level microbiome analysis. Nature Communications, 10, Article 5029. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-019-13036-1
- Quince, C., Walker, A. W., Simpson, J. T., Loman, N. J., & Segata, N. (2017). Shotgun metagenomics, from sampling to analysis. Nature Biotechnology, 35(9), 833–844. https://doi.org/10.1038/nbt.3935
- Salter, S. J., Cox, M. J., Turek, E. M., Calus, S. T., Cookson, W. O., Moffatt, M. F., Turner, P., Parkhill, J., Loman, N. J., & Walker, A. W. (2014). Reagent and laboratory contamination can critically impact sequence-based microbiome analyses. BMC Biology, 12, Article 87. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12915-014-0087-z
- Stevenson, B. S., Eichorst, S. A., Wertz, J. T., Schmidt, T. M., & Breznak, J. A. (2004). New strategies for cultivation and detection of previously uncultured microbes. Applied and Environmental Microbiology, 70(8), 4748–4755. https://doi.org/10.1128/AEM.70.8.4748-4755.2004

No comments:
Post a Comment